Jacksonville orders Keystone to remove coal ash from St. Johns River terminal
The city says the Wigmore Street terminal has been operating a solid waste facility without required local permits, storing ash shipped from Puerto Rico before trucking it out of state.

The City of Jacksonville has ordered a Wigmore Street terminal on the St. Johns River to stop accepting coal ash and to remove material already stored at the site, saying the company has been running a solid waste facility without meeting local permit requirements.
The November 17 order against Keystone Properties LLC and Keystone Investments II, LLC marks the first public enforcement action against the terminal's coal-ash operation, which receives material shipped from a power plant in Puerto Rico, stores it at the riverside facility, and trucks it to an out-of-state landfill. Keystone has 45 days to remove the ash under city supervision or face potential civil penalties of up to $2,000 per day.
What's happening
Under Chapter 380 of Jacksonville's Ordinance Code, any business that stores, processes, or transfers solid waste in Duval County must obtain a Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity, known as a CON. The local requirement is separate from state and federal environmental permits.
The CON process involves review by the city's Solid Waste Division, Environmental Quality Division, Planning and Development Department, and Administrative Services, as well as the Florida Department of Health in Duval County. The City Council then holds a public hearing, with notice sent to nearby property owners, and votes on whether to grant the certificate.
Keystone has never applied for or received a CON for the coal-ash operation at the terminal, according to the city. On October 13, Jacksonville notified Keystone of the potential violation and gave the company 30 days to demonstrate that the operation was authorized. The city says Keystone's response did not provide the information requested, prompting the formal order.
The order requires Keystone to stop receiving any additional solid waste, including coal ash, at the terminal; remove all stored ash within 45 days and deliver it only to a facility lawfully permitted to accept it; control dust and runoff during removal; and report weekly to the city on the amount of ash removed and where it was taken.
Keystone may submit a written response and request a meeting with the city. The company may also apply for a CON, but filing an application does not authorize the operation to continue in the meantime, the order states. The order applies only to solid waste at the facility and does not restrict the terminal's lawful handling of other bulk materials.
Why the permit matters for neighbors
The CON requirement exists in part to give residents near a proposed solid-waste facility a formal voice before operations begin. The public-hearing process mandates notice to nearby property owners and a City Council vote, steps that were bypassed in this case.
Wigmore Street runs through an industrial corridor on Jacksonville's Westside near the St. Johns River and the Blount Island marine terminals. The area is a mix of port-related logistics, manufacturing, and marine operations, with pockets of residential neighborhoods within a mile or two of the terminal.
The notice-and-hearing requirement is designed to let neighbors raise concerns about truck traffic, dust, odors, and potential contamination before a solid-waste operation opens. Without a CON application, no public notice was sent and no council hearing was held, meaning residents had no formal opportunity to weigh in on whether the coal-ash facility should operate at that location.
Projects handling solid waste typically face scrutiny over whether storage and transfer operations could affect nearby air quality, stormwater runoff, and groundwater. The St. Johns River location adds another layer of concern: material stored outdoors at a riverfront terminal is subject to weather, and runoff during storms flows toward the river unless containment systems are in place.
Health and environmental concerns with coal ash
Coal ash—also called coal combustion residuals—is what remains after coal is burned for electricity. According to the U. S. Environmental Protection Agency, it contains contaminants including mercury, cadmium, and arsenic. Without proper management, the EPA says, coal ash can pollute waterways, groundwater, drinking water, and the air.
The city's order cites the EPA's characterization and Mayor Donna Deegan's statement that "coal ash is not a benign material. " The mayor added, "The rules for handling solid waste in Jacksonville apply to everyone, and they exist to protect the people who live and work nearby. The order announced today is about accountability and ensuring that our neighbors are healthy and safe. "
The order requires Keystone to control dust and runoff during the 45-day removal period, an acknowledgment that moving large volumes of ash poses its own risks if not managed carefully. How the material has been stored to date—whether in covered buildings, tarped piles, or open storage—was not detailed in the city's announcement.
Federal and state environmental laws govern the handling and disposal of coal ash, and those regulations apply regardless of local CON requirements. The city's action is based on the local ordinance, not on a finding of state or federal environmental violations, though the lack of a CON means the local review process for health, safety, and environmental standards was never completed.
The logistics and economic footprint
The Keystone terminal's operation involves a multi-modal supply chain: coal ash arrives by ship from Puerto Rico, is stored temporarily at the Wigmore Street site, and is then loaded onto trucks for transport to a landfill outside Florida. The city's order does not name the out-of-state landfill or specify the volume of ash moving through the terminal.
Trucking solid waste long distances is common in Florida, where in-state landfill capacity and tipping fees vary by region. Ash from power plants is typically sent to lined landfills approved to accept coal combustion residuals, a subset of the solid-waste disposal network.
The terminal's location on the St. Johns River gives it direct access to deepwater shipping, a key advantage for bulk materials moving by barge or oceangoing vessel. Industrial terminals along this stretch of the river handle a range of cargoes including aggregates, scrap metal, project cargo, and other bulk commodities. The order applies only to solid waste; Keystone remains free to handle other bulk materials that do not trigger the CON requirement.
The city did not disclose how much coal ash is currently stored at the site or how long Keystone has been operating the coal-ash transfer business. The 45-day removal timeline suggests the quantity is substantial enough to require an extended trucking campaign but manageable within a compressed schedule.
What happens next
Keystone has several options. The company may comply with the order by ceasing coal-ash receipts and removing the stored material within 45 days, with weekly progress reports to the city detailing tonnage and destination. It may submit a written response contesting the city's findings or request a meeting with city officials. It may also file a CON application, though doing so would not allow the operation to continue while the application is under review.
If Keystone does not comply, the city may seek enforcement in court, with civil penalties of up to $2,000 per day for each day of noncompliance. That penalty structure can add up quickly: a 30-day violation would carry a maximum fine of $60,000.
The CON application process, if Keystone chooses that route, would trigger the full sequence of agency reviews and the public City Council hearing that was skipped before. Nearby property owners would receive notice, and residents would have the chance to attend the hearing and speak for or against granting the certificate. The council's decision would hinge on the reviews by the Solid Waste Division, Environmental Quality Division, Planning and Development, Administrative Services, and the Florida Department of Health in Duval County, as well as public input.
No council hearing or administrative hearing date has been set, because Keystone has not yet filed an application or requested a meeting. The immediate legal obligation is the 45-day removal clock, which began when the order was issued on November 17.
A test case as industrial activity grows on the river
The Keystone enforcement comes as Jacksonville's industrial riverfront sees renewed investment. JAXPORT continues to expand container and vehicle-handling capacity at Blount Island and Dames Point, and the Westside industrial corridor—anchored by Cecil Commerce Center farther inland—has become a magnet for logistics and manufacturing projects seeking highway, rail, and deepwater access.
Industrial terminals that handle bulk materials occupy a sometimes-ambiguous space in local regulation: many commodities are exempt from solid-waste permitting, but determining what counts as solid waste and what qualifies as a routine bulk commodity can be a gray area. Coal ash's classification as a contaminant-laden byproduct, combined with its ultimate destination at a landfill rather than a factory or end user, appears to have tipped the city's analysis toward treating it as solid waste subject to the CON requirement.
The case may set a precedent for how the city enforces Chapter 380 when new waste-transfer or recycling operations open at existing marine or industrial sites. The public-hearing and notice provisions of the CON process are designed to ensure transparency, and the Keystone order underscores that those steps are not optional even for businesses operating in heavy-industrial zones.
As Northeast Florida's population grows and development pushes closer to once-remote industrial areas, the buffer between heavy industry and residential neighborhoods continues to shrink. How the city balances port-related economic activity with environmental oversight and neighborhood input will shape the character of the riverfront—and the trust residents place in the permitting process—for years to come.
